LLM Law Outlines Intellectual Property (IP) Law Outlines
IP Law with Former Spring 2019
Based on the book Intellectual Property in the New Technological Age 2018 (Robert P. Merges)...
The following is a more accessible plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Intellectual Property (IP) Law Outlines. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:
02. Copyright Requirements: Originality, Fixation, and Formalities
P. 492-527; 17 U.S.C. §§ 101 (“fixed,” “publication”), 102(a), 104A, 401-402, 406-409, 411-412
A. Introduction
Brief History of Copyright Protection
Invention of the printing press in England made it cheaper and easier to have mass production of books
Second comers can easily print a book without author’s permission people starting to get worried
Crown also worried the information being distributed through the printing press wanted some censorship control over what is being printed
Crown give charter to companies the right to print but authors are not getting much out of this and criticized this law first copyright law:
1710 Statute of Anne: proposed by authors, giving them control over their work. First shift from publisher right to author’s right – also start of the romantic notion of creativity and authorship
Two 14 years period (with option to renew if author survived by the end of the period) created public domain – copyright would expire after a period of time
IP clause became part of the US Constitution
Congress enacted a Copyright Act 1790
Short amount of time: similar to Anne: two 14 year terms + another 14 years.
Need to register and deposit work
Narrow subject matter: only copyright to maps, charts and books
Narrow right: only protects exact publication, doesn’t cover translation, or slight alterations
1909 Copyright Act: still govern some work nowadays
protects ‘all writings’ (including work in progress + speeches) music, performance
initial term 28 yrs + 28 yrs upon renewal
failure to provide proper notice upon publication of a work forfeit protection
Requirement of registration + notice + domestic manufacturing requirements conflicts with European Berne (which prohibits any formal prerequisites to copyright enforcement) US wasn’t eligible for Berne membership
1976 Act and Related Reforms
author’s right of publication, reproduction, distribution, performance, display, derivative work
expanded scope and duration of protection: protects all authorship/ as long as original
all written works became protected upon being “fixed in a tangible medium of expression”, even if unpublished [previously requires publication to trigger copyright protection]
trigger: publication (1909) fixation (1976)
duration: expanded to life of author + 50 yrs or 75 yrs if anonymous
addition 20 yrs protection in 1998 life of author + 70 years
expansion often due to content producers, asking for greater protection
weakened IP protection by establishing several new compulsory licensing regimes, approving numerous exemptions from liability, codifying fair use doctrine (from case law), preempting most case and common law protections that impinge upon federal copyright protection
incorporated protection for computer programs
[Note might have to other legislation other than 1976 nowadays]
Berne Convention Accession 1989
US didn’t want to join, as it includes mural rights
US joined in 1989, had to amended its IP law to comply with min standards
Reduce formalities, extended protection for moral rights and architectural works, restoring copyright for foreign works under protection in the source country but in the public domain in the US
The Digital Age led to amendments to Copyright Act
Audio Home Recording Act 1992
Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act 1995
No Electronic Theft Act 1996
Digital Millennium Copyright Act 1998
Sometimes not so artistic, but functional – can still be creative
An Overview of the Copyright Regime
Elements of protectable copyright
copyrightable subject matter: author’s particular expression of an idea (not idea itself), e.g. literature, song, dance, sculpture, graphics, painting, photography, sound, movies, computer programming
threshold for protection: little originality + fixed in a tangible medium of expression
formalities:
notice required on all work published before 1989
registration not required for validity, but required of US authors prior to instituting an infringement suit
deposit of copies of work required to register
authorship and ownership:
work must have been created by the party bringing suit, or
rights in work must have been transferred by author to party ringing suit
for ‘works made for hire’ – employer is considered the author and owner of the work (not the original creator)
Duration of copyright:
life of author + 70 yrs; or
95 yrs from first publication if anonymous/ pseudonymous/ work made for hire
or 120 yrs from year of creation, whichever occurs first
US Copyright Office register works, but doesn’t conduct search of prior art assess validity
copyright is protectable at the moment the work is created
Ownership of valid copyright confers the following rights:
reproduction: exclusive right to make copies
derivative works: exclusive right to prepare derivative works (based on original, but in different forms altered, e.g. translation, movies based on book)
distribution: right to control sale and distribution (original, derivative, licensed), but no right to resale
performance and display: right to control public (but not private) performance and display of work, including computer programs and other audiovisual works (but no right to prevent)
anti-circumvention: Copyright Act prohibits circumvention of technological protection measures designed to safeguard digitally encoded works, subject to several exceptions
moral rights: attribution to their work, prevent intentional distortion/ modification of their work
Protected against direct and indirect infringement, but rights are limited
fair use doctrine: allow leeway for criticism, comment news reporting, teaching… apples a balancing test to deterine whether a use of copyrighted material should be permitted without owner’s authorisation
Copyright do not give their owner exclusive right to prevent others from making, using or selling their creations
only right to...
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Intellectual Property (IP) Law Outlines.
IP Law with Former Spring 2019
Based on the book Intellectual Property in the New Technological Age 2018 (Robert P. Merges)...
Ask questions 🙋 Get answers 📔 It's simple 👁️👄👁️
Our AI is educated by the highest scoring students across all subjects and schools. Join hundreds of your peers today.
Get Started